Every so often I enjoy a good sentimental story and while this had that element, and also the sweet “Gift of the Magi” twist to it, I finished it feeling frustrated by the lack of depth and the abrupt ending. Some of the main themes in this story were left hanging with out a conclusion. And while I liked the main character and the general storyline, she and others were allowed to get away with behavior that was un-biblical with out consequences. It is a short book filled with emotional tug and some sweet gestures – a quick reading fix – but with out purpose and encouragement. I was able to put the book down with out having been uplifted or challenged in any way. I enjoy Melody Carlson’s writing – what was written was good writing – but the overall story is sadly lacking impact. If you want a book that’s strictly “Christmasy” and emotional then you might enjoy it, but if you want a story that is going to uplift your heart, too, this is not for you.